Method for plant improvement |
|||||||
申请号 | EP14305150.6 | 申请日 | 2014-02-04 | 公开(公告)号 | EP2902411A1 | 公开(公告)日 | 2015-08-05 |
申请人 | Biogemma; | 发明人 | The designation of the inventor has not yet been filed; | ||||
摘要 | The invention relates to the field of plant improvement, in particular of the improvement of yield for plants, by using a transgene containing a BETL promoter driving expression of the IncW2 protein. | ||||||
权利要求 | |||||||
说明书全文 | The invention relates to the field of plant improvement, in particular of the improvement of yield for plants. In the context of the present invention a cereal shall mean in particular maize, rice, wheat, barley, sorghum, millet, oats, rye, triticale (hybrid of wheat and rye), fonio, as well as two pseudocereals, namely buckwheat and quinoa. Maize and wheat are the preferred cereals according to the invention. In agriculture, yield is the amount of product harvested from a given acreage (eg weight of seeds per unit area). It is often expressed in metric quintals (1 q = 100 kg) per hectare in the case of cereals. It is becoming increasingly important to improve the yield of seed crops to feed an expanding population and, more recently, for biofuel production. One strategy to increase the yield is to increase the seed size, provided that there is not a concomitant decrease in seed number. The invention provides a construct which can be used as a transgene for obtaining transgenic plants that have an increased yield with regards to isogenic plants that do not contain said transgene. In particular, the purpose is to have an increased yield, for the transgenic plants, in stressed conditions and in particular in hydric stress conditions (drought), or in heat stress conditions. As intended herein, two plants are said to be "isogenic" when they differ at very few loci (less than 20, more preferably less than 10), and when one does carry the transgene, while the other does not. These plants can also be called "virtually isogenic". The endosperm, which forms most of the volume and weight of the kernel, can be divided into three parts: starchy endosperm, aleurone layer and basal transfer layer. The role of the starchy endosperm is to provide the nutrients to the seed. It is thus mainly composed by cells filled with reserves, such as starch granules, or protein bodies. These cells die during dessication of the seed and this compartment is thus composed of dead cells in mature seeds. The aleurone layer is a one-celled layer of cells in contact with the pericarp. Basically, these cells accumulate lipids and storage proteins. The cells remain active until maturation and play an important role during germination. The basal endosperm transfer layer (BETL) cells are in contact with the pedicel at the base of the endosperm. They transport the nutrients from the mother plant to the embryo surrounding region, as direct transport is not possible since vascular tissue does not extend beyond the pedicel. The invention relates to a nucleic acid construct comprising: a) a promoter active in the BETL, operatively linked to b) a nucleic acid coding for a IncW2 protein, an allele of which is represented by SEQ ID N° 2 (the cDNA is represented by SEQ ID N° 4). It is to be noted that the protein IncW2 is not naturally expressed in the BETL. Consequently, the nucleic acid construct is not found in nature. It is also to be noted that SEQ ID N° 2 represents and exemplifies an allele of the IncW2 protein in maize. There exists different other alleles of this protein, which all possess the same activity than this protein, and can be used in the above-identified nucleic acid construct. One can cite, as such alleles, the proteins that are disclosed in GenBank with the following accession numbers: NP_001105596.1, AAF06992.1, AAF06991.1, AAD02510.1, ACG47298.1. This list is not exhaustive, and other IncW2 proteins can also be used in said nucleic acid construct. These may be identified, by applying the BLASTP program (especially the BLASTP 2.2.29 program) (
The proteins that can be used in the context of the above construct are preferably the ones that present a Max score above 1000. They would also preferably present an identity (as indicated by the BLAST2P software) equal or above 90%, preferably, equal or above 95% more preferably equal or above 97% more preferably equal or above 98%, more preferably equal or above 99%. In a specific embodiment, said promoter active in the BETL is not an imprinted promoter. Some promoters active in the BETL promoters have been described in A promoter "active in the BETL" of a plant is a promoter that allows expression of a nucleic acid sequence operatively linked to it in the BETL of said plant. In a specific embodiment, said promoter is active in the BETL at least during the days following pollination, in particular between 0 and 15 DAP (days after pollination). In another embodiment, said promoter is active in the BETL at least between 0 and 24 DAP. In another embodiment, said promoter is active in the BETL at least between 8 and 24 DAP In another embodiment, said promoter is predominantly functional in the BETL, i.e. said promoter can be active in other tissues than the BETL, but the principal expression of a nucleic acid sequence encoding a protein operatively linked to it is in the BETL. This can be verified, using various techniques known by the person skilled in the art, such as quantification of the RNA expression of said nucleic acid sequence in various tissues by Northern blot, or of the protein expression in various tissues by Western blot. A promoter exclusively expressed in the BETL is active exclusively in the BETL, i.e. it is not possible to detect expression of a nucleic acid sequence encoding a protein operatively linked to it in other tissues than the BETL. In a specific embodiment, said promoter active in the BETL is the BETL9 promoter, the sequence of which is SEQ ID N° 1. It is to be noted that, although SEQ ID N° 1 is herein used to define BETL9, a sequence that is at least 90 % identical, preferably at least 95 % identical, more preferably at least 96 % identical, more preferably at least 97 % identical, more preferably at least 98 % identical, more preferably at least 99 % identical, more preferably at least 99.5 % identical, more preferably at least 99.7 % identical, more preferably at least 99.9 % identical, more preferably at least 99.95 % identical to SEQ ID N° 1 can also be considered as being a BETL9 promoter. This is because it is known that it is possible to change or delete (especially in the 5' end) a few nucleic acids in a promoter without modifying its pattern of expression. Comparing the patterns of expression of a modified promoter and of the promoter depicted by SEQ ID N° 1 can be performed using any reporter gene known in the art, such as the luciferase, GUS or GFP genes. In a specific embodiment, the invention thus relates to a nucleic acid construct (also referred to as an expression cassette) comprising a nucleic acid molecule comprising the BETL9 promoter represented by SEQ ID N° 1, operatively linked to a nucleic acid coding for an INCW2 protein. The BETL9 promoter is also described as sequence 18 from In particular the nucleic acid construct comprises SEQ ID N° 3. In another embodiment, the nucleic acid constructs comprises the sequence between nucleotides 1 and 3773 (or 1 and 3776) of SEQ ID N° 3. The invention also encompasses a vector containing the expression cassette of the invention. A vector, such as a plasmid, can thus be used for transforming host cells. The construction of vectors for transformation of host cells is within the capability of one skilled in the art following standard techniques. The decision as to whether to use a vector for transforming a cell, or which vector to use, is guided by the method of transformation selected, and by the host cell selected. Where a naked nucleic acid introduction method is used, then the vector can be the minimal nucleic acid sequences necessary to confer the desired phenotype, without the need for additional sequences. Possible vectors include the Ti plasmid vectors, shuttle vectors designed merely to maximally yield high numbers of copies, episomal vectors containing minimal sequences necessary for ultimate replication once transformation has occured, transposon vectors, including the possibility of RNA forms of the gene sequences. The selection of vectors and methods to construct them are commonly known to persons of ordinary skill in the art and are described in general technical references ( For other transformation methods requiring a vector, selection of an appropriate vector is relatively simple, as the constraints are minimal. The apparent minimal traits of the vector are that the desired nucleic acid sequence be introduced in a relatively intact state. Thus, any vector which produces a plant carrying the introduced DNA sequence should be sufficient. Also, any vector which introduces a substantially intact RNA which can ultimately be converted into a stably maintained DNA sequence should be acceptable. For transformation methods within a plant cell, one can cite methods of direct transfer of genes such as direct micro-injection into plant embryos, vacuum infiltration or electroporation, direct precipitation by means of PEG or the bombardment by gun of particules covered with the plasmidic DNA of interest. It is preferred to transform the plant cell with a bacterial strain, in particular Agrobacterium, in particular Agrobacterium tumefaciens. In particular, it is possible to use the method described by However, any additional attached vector sequences which confer resistance to degradation of the nucleic acid fragment to be introduced, which assists in the process of genomic integration or provides a means to easily select for those cells or plants which are actually, in fact, transformed are advantageous and greatly decrease the difficulty of selecting useable transgenic plants. The vector can exist, for example, in the form of a phage, a plasmid or a cosmid. The construction of such expression vectors for transformation is well known in the art and uses standard techniques. Mention may be made of the methods described by Sambrook et al. (1989). For transforming bacteria, a vector is generally defined as being a nucleic acid molecule that possesses elements that allows it to be maintained within said host cell (such as an origin of replication that works in this bacterial host cell). The invention also encompasses a host cell containing the expression cassette as described above. The decision as to whether to use a given host cell, or which host cell to use, is guided by the method of transformation. The host cell can be any prokaryotic or eukaryotic cell. Any of a large number of available and well-known host cells may be used in the practice of this invention. The selection of a particular host is dependent upon a number of factors recognized by the art. These include, for example, compatibility with the chosen expression vector, bio-safety and costs. Useful hosts include bacteria such as E. coli sp. or Agrobacterium. A plant host cell, may be also used, notably an Angiosperm plant cell, Monocotyledon as Dicotyledon plant cell, particularly a cereal or oily plant cell, selected in particular from the group consisting of maize, wheat, barley, rice, rape and sunflower, preferentially maize. More particularly, the host cell used in carrying out the invention is Agrobacterium tumefaciens, according to the method described in the article of An et al., 1986, or Agrobacterium rhizogenes, according to the method described in the article of Jouanin et al., 1987. In a specific embodiment, said expression cassette is stably integrated within the genome of said host cell. This embodiment is particularly interesting for plant host cells. Stable integration within the genome means that the expression cassette can be transmitted to the progeny of said host cell upon division. The invention also encompasses a plant containing at least one cell containing the expression cassette as defined above, preferably stably integrated within its genome. A part of a transgenic plant, in particular fruit, seed, grain or pollen, comprising such a cell or generated from such a cell is also encompassed by the invention. It is reminded that a whole plant can be regenerated from a single transformed plant cell. Thus, in a further aspect the present invention provides transgenic plants (or parts of them) including the expression cassette according to the invention. The regeneration can proceed by known methods. The seeds which grow by fertilization from this plant, also contain this transgene in their genome. Said plant or part of a plant according to the invention can be a plant or a part of it from various species, notably an Angiosperm, Monocotyledons as Dicotyledons. It is preferably a cereal or oily plant. As used herein, the term "oily plant" denotes a plant that is capable of producing oil, and preferably that is cultivated for oil production. Said plant is preferably selected from the group consisting of maize, rice, wheat, barley, rape and sunflower. In a preferred embodiment, said plant is maize. In another preferred embodiment, said plant is wheat. The invention thus relates in particular to a transgenic maize or a transgenic wheat, containing at least one cell comprising, stably integrated in its genome, the expression cassette of the invention. In a specific embodiment, said plant, in particular said maize, comprises multiple cells containing, stably integrated in their genome, the expression cassette of the invention. In this embodiment, it is possible that some cells of said plant do not contain the transgene. Due to the use of the BETL9 promoter, expression of the INCW2 protein is thus predominant in the endosperm, and in particular in the BETL, preferably an exclusive pattern expression in the BETL. This may be observed by performing Northern blot on RNA obtained from different organs of the plant, and detecting an expression at least ten times higher in the endosperm, and in particular in the BETL, than in other organs. In another embodiment, said transgene (comprising the expression cassette of the invention) is present in all cells of said plant, in particular said maize or wheat. In another embodiment, the transgene is introduced within the plant cells such as being expressed transiently, or through a genetic construct not integrated in the genome. Thus, agro-infiltration or any other methods, such as injection or spray, are contemplated for transient expression. Hybrid plants obtained by crossing plants according to the invention also form part of the invention, when they contain at least one cell containing the expression cassette of the invention. Any plant as described above can contain one or more transgenes in addition to the cassette according to the invention. One may mention transgenes conferring male sterility, male fertility, resistance to a herbicide (notably glyphosate, glufosinate, imidazolinone, sulfonylurea, L-phosphinotricine, triazine, benzonitrile), resistance to insects (notably a transgene coding for a Bacillus thuringiensis toxin), tolerance to water stress. These plants can be obtained by crossing said plants of the invention with other plants containing said transgenes. Alternatively, plants can be co-transformed with an expression cassette containing several different transgenes, including the transgene of the invention. As demonstrated in the examples, said transgenic plants comprising an expression cassette according to the invention present an increased yield as compared to control plants corresponding to non-transgenic plants not comprising said expression cassette. Said increased yield may be observed in normal conditions or in stress conditions. Increased yield in stress conditions (or stress tolerance) can be measured by the ability of the transgenic plant to maintain yield under stress conditions compared to normal conditions (which is considered to be achieved when the yield observed in stressed conditions is at least 90%, 94%, 95%, 96%, 97%, 98%, 99% or 100% of the yield obtained for the same plant in non-stressed (normal) conditions). It can also be measured by the ability of the transgenic plant to increase yield under stress conditions compared to control plants grown under stress conditions (at least 101%, 102%, 103%, 104%, 105%, 106%, 107%, 108%, 109%, 110%, 111%, 112%, 113%, 114%, 115%). As intended herein, stress conditions comprise specific conditions that are applied to a plant at a specific development stage such as that they induce a yield decrease of at least 8%, 10%, preferentially at least 15% and more preferentially at least 20% between the control plants in normal and in stress conditions. As a matter of illustration, one can cite heat stress conditions that may be applied during the flowering stage (in particular for wheat) or hydric stress before the flowering stage or after the fertilization, (in particular during the grain filling stage for maize). Consequently, the invention also relates to various methods of using the plants of the invention. Therefore, the invention also relates to a method for obtaining a transgenic plant containing at least one cell comprising a transgene comprising the expression cassette as described above, comprising the steps consisting of:
Said generated plant may present an increased yield, in normal or stressed conditions, as compared to an isogenic plant that does not contain said expression cassette in its genome, or shall be able to maintain the yield observed in normal conditions when grown in stressed conditions. In this method, it is clear that the measure of yield is checked by sowing and harvesting of a multiplicity of plants that contain the transgene, the yield of which is then compared with the yield obtained with a second group of plants not containing said transgene, and this under the same culture conditions (sowing and harvest at the same time, on comparable parcels, use of the same amount of fertilizers, water...). It is also clear that comparison is to be performed on a second group of plants that is isogenic to the plants having the transgene. As indicated above, these "isogenic" plants differs from the plants harboring the transgene at very few loci (less than 20, more preferably less than 10), in addition to not carry said transgene. In particular a plant carrying the transgene isogenic to another plant of interest may be obtained by at least four backcrosses in the isogenic plant of interest, followed by at least one self-fertilization. Preferably, the isogenic plants are homozygous lines. Said generated plant can also be used in a selection (breeding) process for obtaining a plant with improved yield. The invention thus also relates to a method for producing a plant that can be used in a selection (breeding) process or scheme for obtaining a plant with improved yield, comprising the step of transforming a plant cell with a vector according to the invention, and regenerating a transgenic plant which comprises at least one cell which contain the transgene comprising the expression cassette as described above. The introgression of the transgene in a given plant is in particular carried out by selection, according to methods known in the art (crossing and self-pollination). The plants are in particular selected using molecular markers. The principle is recalled below:
In addition, it is also possible to accelerate the return to the elite parent by virtue of the molecular markers distributed over the entire genome. At each back cross, the individuals having the most fragments derived from the recurrent elite parent will be chosen. Selection is important as it is often preferable to sow and harvest plant lines that have been optimized, in particular for the location in which they are cultured. Consequently, one needs to introduce the transgene in said adapted lines having otherwise agronomic quality characteristics. The invention also relates to a method for obtaining a plant containing a transgene, wherein said transgene comprises the expression cassette as described above, comprising the steps of
The selection of step c) is preferably performed, by genotyping using molecular markers (for example microsatellite markers), making it possible to define the contribution of each of the two parents to the progeny. One would thus select, in the progeny, plants carrying the transgene and having more markers from the receiver plant line than from the parent containing the transgene. Plants (in particular maize or wheat) which possess the transgene, may also be selected from the progeny, in a conventional manner by molecular biology methods (such as PCR or Southern blotting). The invention also relates to a method for growing a plant, comprising the step of sowing a plant seed, wherein said plant seed contains the nucleic acid construct as described above, and growing plants from this sowed seed. The invention also relates to a method for increasing plant yield under normal conditions for plant harvest, comprising the step of sowing plant seeds, wherein said plant seeds contain the expression cassette of the invention and growing plants from these sowed seeds, and wherein the yield obtained from said grown plants is increased as compared to the yield obtained from isogenic plants grown from seeds which do not contain said expression cassette The invention also relates to a method for increasing or maintaining plant yield under stressed conditions, comprising the step of sowing plant seeds, wherein said plant seeds contain the nucleic acid construct as described above, and growing plants from these sowed seeds, wherein the growing phase is made under stress conditions, and wherein the yield obtained from said grown plants is increased as compared to the yield obtained from plants grown from seeds which do not contain said nucleic acid construct or the yield obtained from said grown plants is maintained as compared to the yield obtained from plants containing said nucleic acid construct and grown in normal conditions. The invention also relates to a method of growing plants, comprising the step of sowing seeds containing the nucleic acid construct as described above, , and growing plants from the sowed seeds. The invention may also comprise the step of harvesting said plants. The invention also relates to a method for harvesting plants comprising the step of harvesting plants of the invention. In particular, in the methods as described above, a hydric stress is applied to the plants during their growth. A method for selecting (screening, identifying) a plant that can be used in a selection (breeding) process for obtaining a plant with improved yield, which comprises the step of selecting, in a population of plants, the plants containing the expression cassette as described above, is also part of the invention. A breeding process for obtaining a plant with improved yield is performed as follows: the yield of a plurality of plants gives the reference yield level which is to be improved. The plant with improved yield is obtained, when the yield observed after sowing and harvesting said plant is higher than the yield of reference. Said plant with improved yield is obtained by known methods in the art, by crossing, back-crossing and stabilizing plants which present a yield In a specific embodiment, the selection is performed through the use of a marker that is specific to the transgene. In this embodiment, the selection step is thus preferably preceded by a step comprising genotyping said population of cereals. In a specific embodiment, the selection step is preceded by a step comprising extracting the RNA from the individuals in said population. In a specific embodiment, the selection step is preceded by a step comprising extracting proteins from the individuals in said population. In a specific embodiment, said population is the progeny obtained from crossing a transgenic plant, wherein said transgene comprises the expression cassette as described above, with a plant line which does not contain said transgene (the receiver plant line). A method for identifying a plant with improved yield, which comprises the step of identifying, in a population of plants, the plants containing the expression cassette as described above, is also part of the invention. Improved yield is determined after comparison with a isogenic plant which does not contain the expression cassette. In a specific embodiment, the identification is performed through the use of a marker that is specific to the transgene. In this embodiment, the identification step is thus preferably preceded by a step comprising genotyping said population of cereals. In a specific embodiment, the identification step is preceded by a step comprising extracting the RNA from the individuals in said population. In a specific embodiment, the identification step is preceded by a step comprising extracting proteins from the individuals in said population. In a specific embodiment, said population is the progeny obtained from crossing a transgenic plant, wherein said transgene comprises the expression cassette as described above, with a plant line which does not contain said transgene (the receiver plant line). The invention also relates to a method for obtaining a hybrid plant, wherein said hybrid plant contains the expression cassette as described above stably integrated within its genome. Said method comprises the step of crossing a first homozygous line, which contains said expression cassette stably integrated within its genome, with a second homozygous line. This plant can be homozygous (if each homozygous parent has the expression cassette as described above stably integrated within its genome) or heterozygous for the transgene present on said expression cassette. In a preferred embodiment, the methods are applied to a cereal (in particular, rice, maize, wheat, barley). It is preferred when said plant is maize or wheat. It is also to be understood that the teachings of the invention make it possible to use sequences that present identity to SEQ ID N° 1 or SEQ ID N° 2 (preferably more than 95, 97, 98 or 99 % identity). Using these similar sequences to produce transgenic plants makes it possible to obtain the same technical effect: increase of yield for these transgenic plants (as compared with isogenic plants not carrying the transgene), in particular in stressed conditions, and specifically in hydric stress conditions. The degree of identity is defined by comparison with the entire sequence of reference. This may be performed using a sequence analysis software, such as the blast program. Using the sequences similarities and such softwares and databases, it is thus possible to identify the orthologs of Incw2 for other cereal plants than maize, that can be used in the invention (as a metter of illustration, one can cite the protein accessible under accession number ABM65157.1, from Sorghum bicolor, or the protein having accession number BAM74037.1 from Triticum aestivum, or the protein having accession numbers Q011S7.2 or NP_001052748.1 from Oryza Sativa, which are all cell wall invertases identified through the blastp program). Preferably, the percentage of identity of two polypeptides is obtained by performing a blastp analysis with the sequence encoded by the nucleic acid according to the invention, and SEQ ID N° 2, using the BLOSUM62 matrix, with gap costs of 11 (existence) and 1 (extension). Similar nucleotide sequences are aligned in order to obtain the maximum degree of homology (i.e. identity). To this end, it may be necessary to artificially introduce gaps in the sequence. Once the optimum alignment has been achieved, the degree of homology (i.e. identity) is established by recording all the positions for which the nucleotides of the two compared sequences are identical, with respect to the total number of positions. It may be obtained using the blastn software, with the default parameters as found on the NCBI web site.
The ZmINCW2 coding sequence was cloned as an EcoRI fragment from anlncW2 cDNA into EcoR1--EcoRI-cut pBIOS503 forming the GATEWAY ENTRY clone pBIOS713. (pBIOS503 is a derivative of pENTRD/Topo (Invitrogen) containing a polylinker with the sites EcoRl - Sall- Sma I- Pst I between the aatL1 and aatL2 recombinase sites.) The BETL9 gene was isolated by Hueros et al (1995). The promoter sequence is, in part, described as pEND1 Patent The 1904bp maize BETL9 promoter was amplified by PCR from genomic DNA of the inbred line F2 using the primers:-
These primers introduce an Xhol and an Xbal site 5' and 3' to the BETL9 promoter. The PCR fragment was cloned as an Xhol, Xbal fragment into Xhol, Xbal-cut pBSKII forming pBETL9-BS. A GATEWAY cassette and a Sac66 polyadenylation sequence was cloned from pBIOS652 as a Hindlll (filled), Sacl fragment into Xbal (filled), Sacl-cut pBETL9-BS thus forming pBIOS710. An LR clonase reaction was performed between pBIOS713 and pBIOS710 thus forming pBIOS740. The pBETL9-ZmINCW2-Sac66 polyA chimeric gene from pBIOS740 was cloned as a partial Xhol fragment into Xhol-cut pBIOS340, forming pBIOS749. (The binary vector pBIOS340 is a derivative of pSB12 (Komari et al.(1996)) containing a pActin+actin intron-Nptll nos polyA chimeric gene for selection of maize transformants). pBIOS749 was transferred into agrobacteria LBA4404 (pSB1) according to Komari et al (1996). Maize cultivar A188 was transformed with these agrobacterial strains essentially as described by Ishida et al (1996). Analysis of the pBETL9-INCW2 transformed corn plants indicated that some plants overexpressed ZmINCW2. Field trials show that seed yield and the stability of yield is improved. Hybrids with a tester line were obtained from T3 plants issued from the INCW2 transgenic maize line (proBETL9 + ZmINCW2 + Sac66 term) chosen according to Example 1. The transformants (T0) plant was first crossed with the A188 line thereby producing T1 plants. T1 plants were then self-pollinated twice, producing T3 plants which are homozygous lines containing the transgene. These T3 plants were then crossed with the tester line thereby leading to a hybrid. This hybrid is at a T4 level with regards to the transformation step and is heterozygous for the transgene. These hybrid plants are used in field experiments. Control hybrids are obtained as follows: Control Equiv corresponds to a cross between theA188 line (the line used for transformation) and the tester line.
These two control lines are used to avoid any effect that could be due to mutations (genetic or epigenetic) coming from in vitro culture. Yield was calculated as follows:
Grain weight is then normalized to moisture at 15 %, using the following formula: As an example, if the measured grain moisture is 25 %, the normalized grain weight will be: normalized grain weight = measured grain weight x 75 / 85. Yield is then expressed in a conventional unit (such as quintal per hectare). Field trials were conducted in 2011 on different locations. Plants were sown between June 15 and June 25 2011. Harvest was between November 10 and November 12, 2011. The experimental block comprises 5 replicates. The experimental design was Randomized complete block or Lattice. Each replicate comprised of two row plots with about 62 plants per plot at a density of 73 800 plants/ha. Controls were used present in this experiment as described above (null segregant T00567 or T 01674 and a control equivalent (A188 crossed with the tester line). Results are represented in Table I, with the yield expressed in (Qx/ha). In said table, "M" means "Mean square", "%" means "% as compared to the control group", "P" means "P-value as compared to the control group". This table demonstrates that the transgenic plants present an increased yield (normalized for moisture) in normal or stress conditions (drought). No other difference of phenotypes were observed for these plants compared to the control plant |