REFRACTIVE INDEX GRADIENT LENS

REFRACTIVE INDEX GRADIENT LENS

Field of Invention

The present invention relates to optical products such as optical lenses and semi- finished lens blanks having a ^< ontinuous progression of power from the distance focus to the near focus, and more particularly to retractive gradient progressive multifocal lenses having a reduced amount of unwanted peripheral astigmatism, and refractive gradient bifocal lenses without a wide blurred blended area defimnε the add zone

Background of the Invention

Commercial multifocal lenses come in a variety ot materials and are generally made of plastic oi glass These lenses come in many styles, sizes, and can be of a lined, blended or progressive design Of these designs, lined bifocals have long been used by those requiring near vision correction The lined bifocal segment is fused in the case of glass, or molded in the case ot plastic In either case, the bifocal segment line is noticeable and represents the junction of near and distance optical portions in the lens or a semi finished blank providing the distance focus and near focus. Bugbee (U S Patent No 1 ,509, 636), Meyrowitz (U S Patent No 1 445.227). and Culver (U S Patent No 2,053.551) teach fused lined bifocals or multifocals While lined bifocals have been used successfully for many years, they have several drawbacks First, they are extremely noticeable and thus are not cosmetically appealing, second, the segment line creates a blur when looking from far to near objects and vice versa, and third, there is an abrupt change of focal length when looking trom tar to near objects and back again No optical area is provided with intermediate power (focal length) at all, unless a lined trifocal is used Blended bifocals, such as those disclosed in W082/03129, are bifocals which retain a clear demarcation between the optical zones with far focus and near focus, however, the line of demarcation is blended to make it far less noticeable Blended bifocals attempt to solve the cosmetic disadvantage of a lined bifocal, but in doing so create a wide blended blur zone when looking from far to near objects and back again, as well as failing to provide intermediate vision

Progressive addition lenses are a type of multifocal lens which incorporate a progression of power changes from far to near correction, creating a progressive vision transition from far to near power and back again Progressive addition lenses represent an attempt to solve the problems discussed above Although progressives solve several deficiencies of lined or blended bifocal lenses they require other compromises in optical design, which in turn compromise the visual function of the lens optic, as discussed below Progressive addition lenses are invisible, and provide a natural transition ot power from far to near foci

Methods of making progressive addition lenses are disclosed, for example, by Harsigny (U S Patent No 5,488,442). Maitenaz (U S Patent No 4,253.747), Maitenaz (U S Patent No 3,687,528), Cretin et al (U S Patent No 3,785,725), Maitenaz (U S Patent No 3,910.691), Winthrop (IJ S Patent No 4,055,379), Winthrop (U S Patent No 4 056.311). and Winthrop (IJ S Patent No 4,062,629) These lenses, however have certain deficiencies which are inherent in their design A first deficiency is that only a relatively narrow reading channel width of about 3-8 mm. defined as the space between two meridional imaginary lines characterized by astigmatism ot +/-0 50 diopters or more This reading channel represents the progressive transition of focal lengths from far to near. enabling one to see from tar to near in a somewhat natural manner without experiencing the abrupt change of power of a lined bifocal A second deficiency is that progressive addition lenses can only provide a relatively narrow reading zone which is about 22 mm wide or less A third major defιcιenc> is the unwanted peripheral astigmatism which is created due to the nature of the progressive optical design This unwanted peripheral astigmatism creates significant visual distortions for the user Manufacturers are interested in limiting the amount ot unwanted astigmatism in order to enhance the visual performance, and thus increase the acceptance levels of their different designs In practice, all progressive lens designs represent compromises among having a lens with the widest possible channel, the lowest amount ot unwanted astigmatism and the widest add power zone A fourth major deficiency is the difficulty of properly fι^ftιn^ιr the patient with a progressive; and. the fifth deficiency is the low tolerance for fitting error allowed by these designs

Numerous attempts have been made to solve the inherent problems discussed above with lined, blended, trifocals, and progressive mulπfocals

H^owever, no other commercially viable options have been found The ophthalmic lens design disclosed in Fπeder (U S Patent No 4.952.048) and Fπeder (U S Patent No 4,869.588) addresses some of these deficiencies, but tails to provide a satisfactory solution due to both manufacturing difficulties and poor cosmetic appearance at moderate to higher add powers Although these patents disclose a lens with several improved features, in the moderate to higher add powers from + 1 75 to +3 00 diopters, this lens caused the front (convex) surface defining the periphery of the near power zone to bulge anteriorly and thus cause a visible optical distortion on either side of the reading zone This feature significantly reduced its commercial appeal Furthermore, difficulties in manufacturing this lens made the lens less commercially viable

Maeda (U S Patent No 4.944,584) discloses a refractive gradient lens using a first partially cured substrate layer A second uncured resin layer is added and diffusion occurs between these two layers during curing to create a third diffusion layer having a refractive index gradient which varies continuously between the refractive indices of the first and second layers To achieve this diffusion layer, the assembly containing the second layer is heated at specified temperatures for 20-26 hours The time required for curing to form the diffusion layer makes this procedure unattractive trom a commercial standpoint Furthermore, it is known that the process disclosed in Maeda, which includes demolding a partially cured lens or semi-finished blank, can create yield problems Thus, while it may be theoretically possible to achieve Maeda 's third, continuously varying, refractive index gradient diffusion layer, actual manufacturing difficulties may reduce the likelihood that the Maeda lens could achieve commercial success

In addition to the deficiencies previously mentioned concerning bifocal and multifocal lenses, these lens styles are ilso thicker than single vision lenses of equivalent distance power, since they are required to provide for additional plus power in the add power zone This added thickness on the anterior surface of the lens tends to detract from their cosmetic appeal and adds additional weight to the lens Several solutions to this problem have been proposed

Blum (U S Patent No 4.873.029) describes the use of a preformed water having desired multifocal segments formed thereon and adding a resin layer of a different index of refraction onto the surface of the preformed wafei In this approach, the preformed water is consumed during the molding process so that the preformed wafer ultimately forms part of the lens While this approach produces a cosmetically improved lens, the process requires hundreds of gaskets and back convex spherical and tone molds These molds ultimately make the concave side of the finished lens Furthermore, with this approach the bifocal or multifocal zone is not invisible due to the significant refractive mismatch needed and the lack of a transition of refractive indices of various materials

Various patents disclose refractive gradient bifocal, muitifocal or progressive lens styles, e g . Dasher (U S Patent No 5,223,862). Maeda (U S Patent No 4,944,584), Yean (U S Patent No 5,258, 144), Naujokas (U S Patent No 3,485,556), Okano (U S Patent No 5.305.028). Young (U S Patent No 3,878.866), Hensler (U S Patent No 3.542,535). and Blum (U S Patent No

4,919,850) However, the commercial production of refractive gradient multifocal ophthalmic lenses to date has not been commercially successful due to chemistry, technology, manufacturing and cost limitations In European Patent Application No PCT/US93/02470, Soane discloses producing a multifocal lens having a bifocal and astigmatic area on the back, concave side of the front optical water preform Soane discloses curing a resin material having a different index of refraction from the optical wafer preform onto the back of the front optical wafer preform using an appropriate back convex mold having the correct curvature This approach, however, requires that a sigmficant number of front optical - reforms be inventoried

In view of the above, it is desirable to have a progressive multifocal lens which would allow the end user a wide and natural progression of vision when looking from far to near being substantially free of unwanted peripheral astigmatism, having a wide reading zone, requiring a smaller inventory of skus (stock keeping units) and being relatively forgiving and easy to fit for the patient In addition, it would be desirable to have a progressive multifocal lens which has substantially the same thickness as a single vision lens of equivalent distance prescription, and which cosmetically is almost invisible in appearance Also, it is desirable to manufacture sucn optical products in a way that reduces the amount ot processing time

Summary of Invention

The present invention solves these and other inconveniences of the prior art by providing an optical product such as a composite refractive gradient progressive multifocal preform, lens or semi-fimshed lens blank and method of manufacture which provides for simply, quickly and inexpensively manufacturing a composite refractive gradient progressive multifocal optical preform, lens, or semi finished lens blank The optical product, such as a lens, compπses a composite of at least three different layers, including a base layer having a region of varying thickness which can be either depressed or raised, a transition zone and an outer layer Each of the layers of the composite are separately applied and are bonded to an adjacent layer or layers In addition each layer has a different and distinct refractive index which allows for a progressive multifocal lens having a wide and natural progression of vision when looking from far to near Interposed between a base layer and an outer layer is a transition zone comprised of at least one transition layer The transition zone has an effective refractive index which is intermediate between the refractive indices of the base and outer layers

Preferably, the effective refractive index is approximately the geometric mean of the refracive indices of the base and outer layers In addition, the lens of the present invention is substantially free of unwanted peripheral astigmatism, incoφorates a wide reading zone and is relatively forgiving and easy to fit for the patient, and possesses a cosmetic appearance which is substantially invisible

In addition, the present invention drastically reduces the number of front optical preforms that must be inventoried For example, assuming add powers ot + 1 00 to -1-3 00 diopters, sphere powers ot -+-4 O to -4 0 diopters, cylinder powers of piano to -2 0 diopters 3 base curves of the lenses, right and left eyes, and assuming the astigmatic power is added as is disclosed by Soane

(PCT/US93/02470) on the concave side of the front optical preform, then for each type of material it would be necessary to inventory the following skus

1 for bifocal lenses - 9,720 different front optical preforms for astigmatic bifocal correction are required, based on 180 different astigmatic degrees x 3 base curves \ 2 eve decentrations x 9 bifocal add powers \ 1 material and

2 for single vision lenses - 540 different front optical preforms for astigmatic correction only are required based on 180 different astigmatic degrees x 3 base curves x 1 material Thus, in the above example Soane would require a total ot 10,260 front optical preforms are required, in addition to back-up inventories that may be required for each sku In contrast, the present invention requires only 540 skus and only 3 pairs of molds based on 180 different astigmatic degrees x 3 base curves x 1 material Furthermore, Soane would require that numerous gaskets and molds to be used and would not produce a bifocal or multifocal zone as cosmetically invisible as the present invention because of the significant refractive index mismatch needed and the lack of a transition layer or layers of different refractive index

Brief Description of the Drawings

FIG 1 is a cross section view of an optical preform according to the present invention

FIG. 2 is a cross section view of an optical preform having a transition layer

FIG 3 is a cross section view of an ontical preform positioned against a mold FIG 4 is a cross section view of a mold positioned against an outer layer

FIG 5 is a cross section view of an optical product according to the present invention.

FIG 6 is a cross section view of an alternate embodiment of the present invention.

Detailed Description

FIG. 1 illustrates a base layer which is an optical preform 10 containing both spherical and astigmatic prescriptions being made of a material having a refractive index of 1 49 and having a spherical convex surface with a modified region 20 which has been modified by mechanical means to form a surface depression which approximately defines the boundaries of the progressive multifocal zone. The modified region 20 could be made on either the convex or concave surface. However, in this embodiment the modification is performed on the convex surface The astigmatic curves or tone surface 30 is located on the concave side For this reason the appropriate tone optical preform is selected and rotated to the appropriate astigmatic axis for the particular prescription needed and the optical modification is performed on the front convex surface in the correct orientation relative to the desired astigmatic axis Not only does the modified region 20 take into account the astigmatic axis needed but also at the appropriate and different decentration location for each of the right and left eyes

Although, for purposes of illustration, mechanical modification of the surface is disclosed, it should be under tood that any method which would create the needed alteration to the surface geometry would work. For example, by way of illustration only, the surface depression can be accomplished by a variety of methods which include stamping, burning, sculpturing, grinding, ablating, and casting The method of obtaimng the surface depression is somewhat dependent on the cure condition of the preform, as well as the composition of the preform material For example, in order to grind the preform, the preform should generally be in a fully cured or hardened condition

The modified region 20 is formed on the optical preform 10 to create a surface depression which will generally define the boundaries of the progressive multifocal zone The desired geometry of the depression can be calculated using known optical formulas pertaining to refractive index In general, nd = n,d , + n₂d₂, where n is the overall retractive index of the optic, d is the thickness of the optic, n , is the refractive index of the optical preform, d , is the thickness ot the optical preform, n_: is the refractive index of the added layer and d₂ is the thickness of the added layer The power at any point is determined by the overall or effective refractive index at that point, which in turn is controlled by the depth of the cavity or depression at that point from the surface contour (sag depth), and the refractive index of the cured resin filling the cavity

Depending upon the modification method used as well as the material of the optical preform, once the modification is performed and the desired surface topography is achieved, the newly altered surface may be further modified bv polishing, surface casting, or other methods known in the an to smooth over a roughened surtace In a preferred embodiment, the mechanically altered surface is mechanically abraded to achieve a rough surface As shown in FIGs 2 and 4. a thin layer of resin is then applied to the entire convex surface of the optical preform 10 including the modified region 20 to form a transition layer 40 which comprises a transition zone 45 In an alternate embodiment, the transition layer can be applied to only a portion of the preform 10 which includes at least the modified region 20

Suitable materials for the optical preform may generally include copolymers of allylics, acrylates, methacrylates. strvenics and viylics. such that the glass transition temperature is between approximately 50°C and 200°C and the refractive index is between approximately 1 44 and 1 56 For example, such materials may include polvfdiethyl bis allyl carbonate), poly-(bιsphenol A carbonate) and poly(styrene)-co-(bιsphenoi \ carbonate dιacrylate)-co-(bιsphenol A carbonate dimethacrylate)

Materials tor the transition zone may generally include copolymers of allylics. acrylates. methacrylates. strvenics and viylics. such that the glass transition temperature is between approximately 50°C and 100°C and the refractive index is between approximately 1 52 and 1 65 For example, such materials may include poly(poly oxy methylene dιacrylate)-co-< ethoxylated bis phenol A carbonate dιacrylate)-co-(furfuryl acrvlate)

The refractive index of the transition layer 40 is purposely formulated to be mismatched to the refractive indices of the preform 10 and a subsequently applied outer layer 50, in order to achieve a transition midpoint of the refractive gradient being achieved. This technique is used in order to render the progressive multifocal area as invisible as possible In addition, when the transition layer 40 is applied to the preform 10. it can prepare the surface of the preform 10 for good bonding with the next resin layer to be applied and can significantly smooth out surface irregularities which might remain and be visible once another resin layer is applied Although the refractive index of the transition layer 40 is formulated to achieve minimum internal reflection from the interface, other embodiments using different surface modification techniques, or optical preforms made of different materials may be used, or the retractive index of the coating may be formulated to be closer to that of the optical preform or to that of the next resm layer to be applied, or may not even be needed As shown in FIG. 6, an alternative embodiment of the present invention may have at least one additional transition layer 40, with the transition layers being placed on top of each other after partially or fully curing each layer Each transition layer 40 has a different refractive index such that the layers collectively form a transition zone 45 which has an effective retractive index that is approximately the geometric mean of the optical preform 10 and the outer layer 50 Having a transition zone with an effective retractive index approximating the geometric mean makes the transition of retractive indices less abrupt and thus make the linished multifocal zone more invisible Although the effective retractive index should approximate the geometric mean, a variation of +/- 03 units produces acceptable results

Suitable materials for the outer layer 50 may generally include copolymers of allylics, acrylates, methacrylates, strvenics and viylics, such that the glass transition temperature is between approximately 60°C and 225°C and the refractive index is between approximately 1 56 and 1 70 For example such materials may include ethoxylated bisphenol A diacrylate, ethoxylated bisphenol A dimethacrylate, ethoxylated 1 ,4-dιbromo-bιsphenol A diacrylate. bιs(4- acryloxyethoxyphenyDphosphine oxide, 1 4-dιvιny! benzene, bromostyrene. and vinylcarbazole

In other embodiments of the present invention, an additional resin layer or layers may be interposed between the base layer and the transition zone Also. additional resin layers can be interposed between transition layers in the transition zone or between the transition zone and the outer layer or layers This additional layer or layers should have a surface energy that sufficiently matches adjacent layers so that the resin can provide the desired degee of coating of the underlying layer

Although in the preferred embodiment the transition layer 40 is applied by brushing, the layer may also be applied by other techniques readily known in the an For example, such techniques as spin coating, dip coating, spray coating or other^1* may be used

Once the transition layer 40 is applied to the convex surface of the optical preform 10, the transition layer 40 is preferably partially cured The curing process may be performed with any known curing method including a thermal cure. UN cure, visible light cure, or combination thereof , in the absence or presence of oxygen using the appropriate initiators, atmospheric environment, and curing source In the preferred embodiment, the transition layer 40 is pamally cured in an oxygen free nitrogen environment using ultraviolet light within the range of approximately 250-400 nm However, use of visible light within the range of about 400-450 nm in an oxygen free nitrogen environment also may be used When a UV source is used for cunng, the optical product can be rapidly manufactured since the curing time for a transition layer can be less than five minutes and generally will not exceed an hour

As shown in FIGs 3 and 4, once the modified region 20 is formed in the optical preform 10 to achieve the desired surface topography and the desired transition zone 45 is applied, the optical preform with the transition zone 45 is ready to be provided with an outer layer 50 which is preferably formed by casting a resin onto the transition zone 45 The outer layer 50 is formulated to have a refractive index significantly different from the optical preform 10 material In the preferred embodiment, the resm of the outer convex layer 50 is formulated to have a refractive index of about 1 66. the optical preform 10 material has a refractive index of about 1 49; and the refractive index of the transition layer 40 is a constant of about 1 57 Thus, the 1 66 refractive index convex outer layer 50 is cast from a resin onto the 1 574 refractive index convex transition layer 40 which is affixed to the 1 49 retractive index optical preform 10 This is preferably done in this example using a single vision spherical mold 60 which is selected to cast the desired outer convex curvature onto the optical preform 10 having the transition layer 40 If the convex curvature of the opncal preform 10 is aspheric in design, the appropriate single vision mold selected for SurfaceCastmg the outer convex surface will be an aspheric design rather than spherical design. This outer curvature will control the desired distai ce power achieved Appropriate techniques tor providing the cast layer are descπbed in Blum (U.S Patent No 5, 178,800) ( '"800"), Blum (U S Patent No. 5, 147,585) ( '"585"), Blum (U S Patent No 5,219,497) ( "-497"), and Blum (U S Patent No 4.873.029) ( O29"), however, using a single vision mold The contents ot these patents are incorporated herein by reference These techniques are also commercially available trom Innotech. Inc. by way of its Excahbur^® SurfaceCastmg^® system

The mold 60 used to cast the outer layer 50 can be made out ot any applicable material allowing for proper cure By way of example only, electroformed nickel, glass, and plastic disposable molds can be used Prior to the curing process, the resin used to cast the outer layer 50 can be dispensed into the mold 60. dispensed into a cavity 70 between the mold 60 and the preform 10, or provided in the form of a pamally cured polymeric layer included with the mold 60 or attached to the optical preform 10 In embodiments where the outer layer 50 is produced from a partially cured polymeric layer which is later cured, the transition layer 40 or layers which produce the retractive index transition zone 45 can be attached to the partially cured polymeric outer layer 50 In this case, the partially cured polymeric layer and attached refractive index transition layer 40 are then cured and formed onto the optical preform 10 Although the preferred embodiment does not use a gasket while casting the outer convex curvature onto the optical preform, in certain embodiments a gasket may be used.

When the transition zone includes a plurality of layers, the refractive index of each layer is selected so that the transition zone has an effective refractive index that is approximately the geometric mean of the preform and the outer layer By way of example only, if the preform has a refractive index of about 1 50 and the outer layer has a refractive index of about 1 70, the refractive indices of three transition layers in a transition zone may be about 1 54, 1 60 and 1 66 as the layers progress trom the preform to the outer laver

The transition zone 45 is comprised of a distinct and separately applied layer or layers, wherein each layer has a different refractive index and is formulated so that the transition zone 45 has an effective retractive index which is intermediate and approximates the geometric mean of the retractive indices of the optical preform 10 and the outer layer 50 The retractive index ot each transition layer in the transition zone is generally constant throughout the entire laver

During the cure step, the partially cured transition layer 40 as well as the SurtaceCast resin outer layer 50 become cured to the desired degree to form a refractive index gradient progressive multifocal optical lens, or semi-finished blank In the case of the preferred embodiments, the refractive index gradient vanes from about 1 40 to 1 66, with different thicknesses of each material being defined by the geometries of the convex surface topography of the modified optical preform, the concave spherical and astigmatic surface topography of the optical preform and the single vision spherical concave mold surface which adds the desired outer convex curve onto the convex side of the modified and customized optical preform to achieve the desired power Irmotech ^'s

SurfaceCastmg commercial product typically applies a surface layer in a manner so that the distant power of the desired prescription is not substantialh changed However, in the present invention the outer layer may or may not be confined to leaving the distant power substantially unchanged Furthermore, unlike Irmotech 's commercial SurfaceCastmg technology and the technology of the -800. -585, 029 and *491 patents, the progressive addition multifocal region of the present invention is not added by way of a multifocal mold but rather is created due to the altered surface topography of the optical preform 10 as well as the refractive index gradient which results from casting a spherical or aspheric surface onto an altered surface topography which is specifically altered to cause different varying thickness of a refractive gradient.

Referring to FIG 5, once the castinq process is completed, the composite refractive gradient progressive multifocal lens 100 is removed from the mold 60 The newly formed composite lens 100 can be post cured in the mold or outside of the mold by techniques which are well known in the art.

The method of the present invention can be used to make optical preforms, optical lenses, and optical semi-finished blanks. Resins used to form any and all layers can be photochromatic if desired, so long as the proper refractive index is achieved for the particular layer In addition, although the preferred embodiment has been illustrated by using resins to form the layers, it is understood that the layers of the composite can also be made from a glass or a combination of resin and glass.

The outer layer of the newiy formed composite lens 100 can be surface treated in any manner used in the optical industry, including applications of anti- reflective coatings, scratch resistant coatings, tints, photochromatic coatings and or photochromatic impregnation techniques, soil resistant coatings, etc. Furthermore, in-mold transfer of various coatings can also be utilized as part of the fabrication process as opposed to being applied after the lens or semi-finished blank is fabricated.

The present invention provides bifocal add powers and the desired decentration for the right and left eyes, and establishes the correct optical tone axis. These results are preferably accomplished by modification of the convex surface of the optical preform. In other embodiments of the invention, the modification to the geometry of the optical preforms can be made by modifying the concave side of the optical preform in the same or similar manner as the modification is done to the convex surface. In this case, the optical preform surface modification and casting are performed on the concave side of the optical preform as opposed to the front side of the optical preform

Also, in certain other embodiments, the surface topography modification of the optical preform can be made with a certain depth and geometry and aligned opposite a bifocal or multifocal zone of a mold contaimng the appropriate surface curvature needed This is done to add not only the appropriate outer curvature, but also to add additional confining geometry in the region of the bifocal or multifocal zone of the finished lens. By using this approach, it is possible to use materials having a smaller index of refraction differential than the materials used in the preferred embodiment